Fair and Not-So-Fair Use
It’s no secret that I’m a big fan of Kansas State University anthropology professor Michael Wesch. I’ve shared his excellent videos (A Vision of Students Today, The Machine is Us/ing Us, and Information R/evolution) with colleagues and students alike.
This weekend I came across two different videos that draw on his work.
The first one uses the same Creative-Commons-Licensed music and video production techniques as The Machine is Us/ing Us to raise questions about 21st Century Skills. I think this video is a very nicely-done homage, and I’m glad to see that the Social Studies Department at Weymouth High School credits Wesch for the “creative inspiration and music” (the music is actually “There’s nothing impossible” by Deus). All in all this is a nice example of fair use – adapting a creative concept to a new purpose.
I also came across a video posted by McGraw Hill, which was basically just a bunch of footage from A Vision of Students Today and The Machine is Us/ing Us with additional text occasionally interspersed between clips. I wasn’t really interested in watching the whole video, but I waited until the end to see if they gave Wesch any credit. They didn’t!


The good new is, when I tried to link back to the McGraw Hill video today, I got the “This video has been removed by the user” message. So I’m glad they recognized that this was not fair use and responded so promptly to Wesch’s comment on the video. I’ll be sharing this story with my students as an example of digital citizenship in action!



























Recent Comments